With the passing of Herman Wouk on May 17 at 103, we can
remember his great masterpiece The Caine Mutiny about sailors on a World War II destroyer minesweeper who mutiny
against their incompetent Captain Queeg. Wouk wrote The Caine Mutiny play and for a while worked on the script for the
movie in which Humphrey Bogart gave an Oscar winning performance as Captain
Queeg in the Caine Mutiny movie.
The basic facts underlying the
court-martial case are that Lieutenant Stephen Maryk relieves Queeg of command
of the USS Caine when Captain Queeg freezes up during a typhoon. Maryk has a
belief from Queeg’s prior behavior that he is mentally unbalanced. Maryk is on
trial for conduct to the prejudice of good order and discipline.
Lieutenant Greenwald’s
cross-examination of Queeg is the high point in the movie. Beyond that, it is a
superb illustration of how to conduct a concession-seeking cross-examination. The
concession-seeking cross-examination strategy is discussed at length in Cross-Examination Handbook.
Time after
time, Greenwald confronts Queeg with truths that Queeg must concede or stamp his answer as either a lie, mistaken or
ridiculous. Why must Queeg concede?
It is because Greenwald can prove what he is asserts either by circumstantial
or direct evidence or by plain common sense. Greenwald knows the answers to
every cross-examination question he asks.
It is Greenwald’s turn to testify,
not Queeg’s. It’s his opportunity to lay out the truths. These truths all
support the ultimate conclusion—Queeg is unstable and unfit for command.
Here are those truths: (1) Queeg
steamed over the Caine’s tow line; (2) Queeg was distracted during the towing
maneuver because he was reprimanding a seaman over an un-tucked shirt; (3)
Queeg having just testified that Maryk was unfit had previously written a glowing
fitness report about him; (4) Queeg ordered that the Caine steam ahead of an
attack force, drop a yellow dye marker and retreat; and (5) Queeg was obsessed
with a search for a key that would have led to a missing quart of strawberries
when he had been told by an officer that the mess boys had eaten the
strawberries. When confronted by Greenwald with the fact that the officer who
told Queeg about the mess boys eating the strawberries could be called to
testify, Queeg loses his composure, rolling two metal balls around in his hand
as he babbles on (masterful performance by Bogart).
Naturally, Maryk is acquitted.
